Thursday, July 18, 2013

When Generosity Becomes Toxic

For the past five years and a half years, our church has been actively involved in projects that assist, come alongside and provide much needed help to a variety of citizens in our community.  This has been rewarding and at times, very successful.  Many a servant has been able to step outside of their comfort zone, realize a great sense of fulfillment, and invest not only their life, but a fair amount of money into these altruistic ventures.  As we look back on what has been accomplished, I feel we can say, "...well done!"

However, as of late, I am having a shift in my thinking when it comes to these types of outreaches. Namely, albeit our heart and motives have been pure, I'm not real sure we've actually helped those in need.  Yes, we've given a cup of cold water on a hot day, we've provided hotel rooms for a weary soul and, we've put food in the belly of literally thousands.  And, we will continue to do this; still, I wonder if there's a better approach, a more effective method... a system, if you will, that will empower and equip those we help to facilitate change and a future good for them.
Recently, I tweeted on my Twitter account the following, "Generosity becomes toxic when we perpetuate a spirit of kindness into the life of the broken without providing tools to become healthy."  I had a variety of responses; responses from '... right on!' to, '... what?'  My Facebook account had posts that said, "I really need to ponder this one!"  And, "... that's a great idea when it comes to the helps ministry."

You've heard the adage, "Don't give someone fish, teach them how to fish!"  I've always liked this; however, I think we should take this further: how about giving them a tackle box with the necessary ingredients to be successful and self sufficient?  To many a time our heart and love for others supersedes a pragmatic, practical approach to helping those in need.  And, in the long run, we create a dependency on the system rather than a sense of pride on behalf of those being helped.

Robert Lupton, an author out of Chicago, writes, "... when relief does not transition to development in a timely way, compassion becomes toxic."  I am coming to own the fact that if we cannot provide tools to break a cycle of brokenness in the life of those hurting, all we do is enhance that cycle of brokenness and destructive behavior.

I was sharing my thoughts with my good buddy, retired cop Hannibal the other day over lunch.  We both have come to the conclusion that we must, if we want to effectuate change, have an effective systematic approach to provide care coupled with practical application to those we assist.  To many a time we've served, invested time and energy into folks that simply want a hand out & could care less about change; folks that, sad to say, have allowed their existence in this cycle of hurt and brokenness to define them.  Now, this might sound judgmental and mean - at a first glance, I guess it does.  But, in all honesty, both Richard and I, & our plethora of servants in Morro Bay would drop everything to help someone in need that truly wants a new start, a new beginning.

Hannibal calls my boss my 2,000 year old Rabbi.  I like this and it's to His example that we try and emulate at the church I serve at.  One day, Jesus was walking through a village and there was a man who had been crippled for 38 years.  As Jesus walked by, he began to yell, "Master, heal me.  Heal me!"  Jesus responded with a statement that has been ringing in my ears these past few months: he told the guy to, "... pick up your mat and walk!"  In other words, the principle back then is the same principle today: take ownership of your situation, and take that first step toward health.  And, keep walking toward a newly found freedom that life promises.

This is where my heart is at these days.  I don't have all the answers, that's for sure.  But I do know that the way we do business has to change.  Currently, we are in the process of evaluating how we do our helps ministry and it is my hope that we can develop, mentor and guide those caught in the cycle of brokenness.  To provide means to win, to help break a cycle of destruction and to facilitate change to a productive fulfilling life... a life our Maker intended for us to live!

Thanks for hearing me out.  As you can tell, my thoughts are being formulated and my paradigm for helps is changing.  I would appreciate your thoughts and prayers as we charge into the days ahead with the hope of effectuating change in the lives of those we help.